• Press
  • Offices
  • Contact
  • Legal notice
  • EN
    • DE
  • UPC
  • UPC
  • Firm
    • Main Focus
    • History
    • Guiding Principle
    • Awards and Rankings
  • Our Practice
    • Legal Areas
    • Industries
  • Our Team
  • News & Events
    • News
    • Events
    • UPC-Update
    • IP-Update
    • Brexit-Update
    • Publications
    • B&B Bulletin
  • Career
    • Working with us
  • Menu Menu
FIND EXPERTS
  • UPC
  • Firm
    • Main Focus
    • History
    • Guiding Principle
    • Awards and Rankings
  • Firm
  • News & Events
    • News
    • Events
    • UPC-Update
    • IP-Update
    • Brexit-Update
    • Publications
    • B&B Bulletin
  • FIND EXPERTS
  • Contact
  • Our Practice
    • Legal Areas
    • Industries
  • Our Practice
  • Our Team
  • Career
    • Working with us
  • Career
  • Offices
  • EN
    • DE

Interplay between infringement and revocation proceedings in the Unitary Patent System

18. October 2022/in Unitary Patent Court, UPC Overview

In the Unitary Patent System, the Unified Patent Court (UPC) has jurisdiction over both infringement and revocation actions. However, under certain conditions, an infringement action and a parallel revocation action may be decided by different divisions of the UPC.

In the Unitary Patent System, claims for injunctive relief and damages arising from European patents can be enforced in several EU countries through centralized infringement proceedings before the Unified Patent Court (UPC). As a defense against such infringement actions, the validity of the patent may be challenged.

The validity can be challenged (irrespectively of whether an infringement action is pending) by means of an opposition against the European patent with the European Patent Office (within the opposition period). Apart from this, it is possible to file (even after opposition proceedings before the European Patent Office have been concluded) a national revocation action against a national part of the European patent (during the transitional period of seven years after the Unitary Patent System comes into force), and a revocation action before the UPC against the Unitary Patent or the parts validated in the member states of the Unitary Patent System. In addition, when an infringement action is pending before the UPC, the validity of the Unitary pPatent can be challenged by means of a revocation counteraction.

In the German patent system the bifurcation principle applies, according to which infringement and revocation actions are decided by different courts. By contrast, in most other European patent systems one and the same court can jointly decide on both infringement and validity. In the Unitary Patent System, these two principles are combined: On the one hand, the UPC has jurisdiction over both infringement and revocation actions, while on the other hand, an infringement action and a parallel revocation action may under certain conditions be decided by different divisions of the UPC. Namely, the local or regional division before which the infringement action is pending may, after hearing the parties, decide at its discretion to:

a) proceed with both the infringement action and the revocation counteraction while allocating a technically qualified judge,

b) refer the revocation counteraction for decision to the central division and suspend or proceed with the infringement action, or

c) with the agreement of the parties, refer the entire case for decision to the central division.

Thus, in cases a) and c), infringement and validity are decided by the same division, whereas case b) corresponds in a way to the German bifurcation principle. However, whether in particular the German local divisions, which are expected to receive most infringement actions in Europe, will choose alternative b) and thus relinquish competences assigned to them, may be doubted, but it remains to be seen how the courts will handle this in practice. Furthermore, the patent proprietor will in general not agree to alternative c), because he has already decided to file the infringement action with the respective local or regional division, and the transfer to the central division could delay the case.

The situation is more complicated if an independent revocation action is pending before the central division and the patent proprietor only subsequently files an infringement action before a local or regional division against the plaintiff in the revocation action, so that the revocation and the infringement proceedings are initially separated. In this situation, the plaintiff in the revocation action (defendant in the infringement action) may file a revocation counteraction in addition to its central revocation action. The central revocation proceedings are then in general suspended, and the local or regional division may proceed at its discretion as described above. For example, it may then reconnect the two actions according to options a) or c). However, in exercising its discretion, the local or regional division must take into consideration the status of the central revocation proceedings.

Finally, infringement proceedings before the UPC may also be suspended if there are pending invalidity proceedings before the European Patent Office or a national authority, at least when a decision in the invalidity proceedings may be expected to be given rapidly.

 

Local or regional division decides at ist discretion:Revocation counteractionInfringement action
a)ProceedProceed
b)Refer to central divisionProceed
b)Refer to central divisionSuspend
c) (with agreement of the parties)Refer to central divisionRefer to central division

 

Back to page Unitary Patent Court
/wp-content/uploads/2022/04/boehmert_logo.svg 0 0 Petra Hettenkofer /wp-content/uploads/2022/04/boehmert_logo.svg Petra Hettenkofer2022-10-18 12:01:392022-12-01 13:22:48Interplay between infringement and revocation proceedings in the Unitary Patent System

Author

Dr. Giulio Schober

Contents

More articles

  • Unitary Patent: costs 18. November 2022
  • Introduction: What is the Unitary Patent System? 14. September 2022
  • When will the new system become operational? 14. September 2022

Menu

  • Firm
  • Our Practice
  • Career
  • News & Events
  • FIND EXPERTS

Informations

  • Press
  • Contact
  • Legal notice
  • Data Protection
  • General Terms and Conditions
  • Contact

Legal Areas

  • Employee Inventions
  • Data Protection
  • Designs
  • Domains
  • Information Technology
  • Anti-Trust
  • Licensing
  • Trade Marks
  • Patent Valuation
  • Patents & Utility Models
  • Patent Litigation
  • Product Piracy
  • Copyright
  • Unfair Competition

© Copyright 2023– BOEHMERT & BOEHMERT

Scroll to top
Cookie settings Cookie settings

We need your consent before you can continue to use our website.


If you are under 16 and wish to give your consent to volunteer services, you must ask your parent or guardian for permission. We use cookies and other technologies on our website. Some of them are essential, while others provide you with more advanced information. For more information about how we use your data, please see our Data Protection Policy. There is no obligation to consent to the processing of your data in order to use this offer. You can revoke or adjust your selection at any time under Settings. Please note that due to individual settings, not all functions of the website may be available.

Cookie settings

Accept all cookies

Save settings

Accept only essential cookies

Individual data protection settings

Cookie details Privacy policy Legal notice

Cookie settings Cookie settings

If you are under 16 and wish to give your consent to volunteer services, you must ask your parent or guardian for permission. We use cookies and other technologies on our website. Some of them are essential, while others provide you with more advanced information. For more information about how we use your data, please see our Data Protection Policy. There is no obligation to consent to the processing of your data in order to use this offer. Please note that due to individual settings, not all functions of the website may be available. Here you can find an overview of all cookies used. You can give your consent to entire categories or view more information and thus select only certain cookies.

Accept all cookies Save settings Accept essential cookies only

Back

Cookie settings

Essential cookies enable basic functions and are necessary for the proper functioning of the website.

Display cookie information Hide cookie information

Name
Provider Borlabs GmbH, Legal notice
Purpose Stores the settings of the visitors selected in the Cookie Box of Borlabs Cookie.
Data protection policy https://borlabs.io/privacy/
Cookie name borlabs-cookie
Cookie duration 1 year

Privacy policy Legal notice